Showing posts with label Tree Canada. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Tree Canada. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 21, 2007

How not to offset the Green House Gas emissions from your campaign travel

In mid-January of 2006, during the federal election campaign, Canadian Green party leader Jim Harris released the following:

The Green Party will completely offset the greenhouse gas pollution produced by the leader's tour by planting enough trees to absorb all of these emissions, said Green Party of Canada leader Jim Harris today.

Tree Canada Foundation certified the Green Party of Canada's leader's campaign carbon-neutral today in Ottawa. Harris submitted the total number of travel miles he and his media team will have covered in this election to be offset by an investment in carbon reserves that trap greenhouse gas emissions responsible for climate change.

The Tree Canada Foundation had the following news release:

The Tree Canada Foundation certified the Green Party of Canada's leader's campaign carbon-neutral today in Ottawa. Harris submitted the total number of travel miles he and his media team will have covered in this election - Tree Canada calculated that in 20 years, the 131 trees planted in the Spring of 2006 will absorb the 16 tonnes of carbon dioxide Harris produced in the travel for his campaign.

In addition, Tree Canada certified the 14 Saskatchewan Green Party candidates as well, overseeing the planting of 314 trees to offset their campaign travel as well.


Oops, that 20 years got lost in the Green Party press release. The problem with the Green party's rather sloppy offset is that the offset will only have occured if, after 20 years, the trees survive insects, fire, cutting, and then mature into a permanent forest. Who is there to guarantee that? If the land had been left to itself, would it not have sprouted trees on its own? Does this forestry project satisfy additionality? Unfortunately the Tree Canada website does not answer these questions and does not record any details of the trees it 'planted'. I've sent an email to them (March 21, 2007) asking for information. One clue is that Tree Canada sells offsets through cleanairpass.com. That organization buys credits on the Chicago Climate Change (CCX) I believe and perhaps bought afforestation or reforestation credits on the CCX from some counterparty. I believe it is a fair statement that tree-planting is a controversial Green House Gas offset, and requires at minimum a careful accounting, best made public so that it can be verified.