Liberals shouldn't have followed Conservatives on partisan ten percenters

The Globe and Mail carried a story on July 30, Liberals slapping back against Tories' partisan flyer tactics, about how Liberal MPs have now also started to send out partisan "ten percenters" after complaining about the Conservatives' ten percenters to no avail.

Other Liberal bloggers have applauded this move, but I disagree.

The partisan ten percenters had been energizing and motivating Liberal party supporters and other voters. A lot of people were angry at these mailings, told us so, and I think we could have capitalized (were capitalizing!) on them to build up our own organization.

Instead, this is looking like out-of-control, pre-writ, partisan mud-slinging funded, unwillingly I am certain, by the tax-payer. It's not going to help us solve some of the structural problems with Canadian democracy like voters getting turned off by politics and disengaging from the political process. (problems that Conservatives are less concerned about, since it serves their interests)

My feeling is that Liberals are not going to realize a net profit by choosing this route. I can't see, for example, that it's going to help the Liberal party pick up members and supporters.